Potential New Rubric/Template

Due to some suggestions I made a rubric that is slightly different. If you think further changes should be done please post below what you think should be done or if you think this is good as it is.



Match 1: ?/10

Each win rewards 4 points. Win the match with no losses gives a bonus 2 points.

-------

Deck Construction Total: ?/17

Number of Cards: ?/2

Consistency and Synergy: ?/9

I combined consistency and synergy because most of the same reasons effected both of them, however they do have some slight differences.

Originality: ?/4

Side Deck Number of Cards: ?/2

-------

Performance Total: ?/16

Focus: ?/2

Use of Cards: ?/8

Siding: ?/6

-------

Match 2: ?/10

Each win rewards 4 points. Win the match with no losses gives a bonus 2 points.

-------

Deck Construction Total: ?/17

Number of Cards: ?/2

Consistency and Synergy: ?/9

I combined consistency and synergy because most of the same reasons effected both of them, however they do have some slight differences.

Originality: ?/4

Side Deck Number of Cards: ?/2

-------

Performance Total: ?/16

Focus: ?/2

Use of Cards: ?/8

Siding: ?/6

-------

Ruling: ?/8

3 ruling questions (2 points each) as well as 2 points for in game ruling. As always the tester can try to make fake rulings or cheat to see if the other will catch. As always do not continue to play with these fake rulings.

Attitude: ?/3

Deck Variety: ?/3

Total: ?/100

Carbuncle Red: 0-65
Tiger Yellow: 66-87
Pegasus Blue: 88-100

I like it but the way the number are from a tester point of view are a bit messy ill post what i am thinking in a little bit

Match 1: ?/10
Each win rewards 4 points. Win the match with no losses gives bonus 2 points.

-------
Number of Cards: ?/2

Consistency and Synergy: ?/8

Originality: ?/4

Side Deck Number of Cards: ?/4
0-5, 1 pts
6-10, 2pts
11-14, 3pts
15, 4pts
Deck Construction Total: ?/18

-------
Focus: ?/4

Use of Cards: ?/5

Siding: ?/6
Performance Total: ?/15
(So first duel is worth 43 points)
-------

Match 2: ?/10
Each win rewards 4 points. Win the match with no losses gives bonus 2 points.
-------

Number of Cards: ?/2

Consistency and Synergy: ?/8

Originality: ?/4

Side Deck Number of Cards: ?/4
0-5, 1 pts
6-10, 2pts
11-14, 3pts
15, 4pts
Deck Construction Total: ?/18
-------
Focus: ?/4

Use of Cards: ?/5

Siding: ?/6
Performance Total:? /15
(So Second duel is worth 43 points/ so both are worth 86 pts)
-------

Ruling: ?/8

3 ruling questions (2 points each) as well as 2 points for in game ruling. As always the tester can try to make fake rulings or cheat to see if the other will catch. As always do not continue to play with these fake rulings.
(ruling bring the points up to 94)

Attitude: ?/3

Deck Variety: ?/3

Total: ?/100
Carbuncle Red 0-60
Tiger Yellow 61-89
Pegasus Blue 90-100

To be fair, in many tests, including dorm tests, many things are subjective. People will get graded by the opinion of a tester, which I try to take experienced players. That way the opinion is from someone experienced. Our tests are only slightly different. Also in your rubric you have it almost exactly the same, just slight increases and decreased. Why do you think it should be with those?

i agree with the new rubric

mainly to focus on the the important of the side deck

After thinking about it I decided as long as nobody gives a compelling argument we will probably go off of that rubric.

What do you guys think about me mixing synergy and consistency into one?

Im 100% good with it

wait so quick question, if the new rubric does go through does it effect previuos test's? cuz i got a 68 and i wud b in tiger yellow .-.

No. Everyone will stay in the current dorm they are in, however when they retest they will use this system and new members will use it as well. Erma, if you notice the 32 point drop, that would be about 25% less total score. Presuming you would score the same way percentage wise, then you would get about 53ish. The fact the total score dropped is what makes it have no affect on previous test scores.

kk i get it and i cant wait to buy a retest then  

so are we completely switching now to this new testing, I am in the middle of testing Shinuka, but my net keeps going down so i would like to know what one to use. thank you

How about we use your test setup, however we use my system for score requirements?

So this :
Match 1: ?/10
Each win rewards 4 points. Win the match with no losses gives bonus 2 points.

-------
Number of Cards: ?/2

Consistency and Synergy: ?/8

Originality: ?/4

Side Deck Number of Cards: ?/4
0-5, 1 pts
6-10, 2pts
11-14, 3pts
15, 4pts
Deck Construction Total: ?/18

-------
Focus: ?/4

Use of Cards: ?/5

Siding: ?/6
Performance Total: ?/15
(So first duel is worth 43 points)
-------

Match 2: ?/10
Each win rewards 4 points. Win the match with no losses gives bonus 2 points.
-------

Number of Cards: ?/2

Consistency and Synergy: ?/8

Originality: ?/4

Side Deck Number of Cards: ?/4
0-5, 1 pts
6-10, 2pts
11-14, 3pts
15, 4pts
Deck Construction Total: ?/18
-------
Focus: ?/4

Use of Cards: ?/5

Siding: ?/6
Performance Total:? /15
(So Second duel is worth 43 points/ so both are worth 86 pts)
-------

Ruling: ?/8

3 ruling questions (2 points each) as well as 2 points for in game ruling. As always the tester can try to make fake rulings or cheat to see if the other will catch. As always do not continue to play with these fake rulings.
(ruling bring the points up to 94)

Attitude: ?/3

Deck Variety: ?/3

Total: ?/100

Carbuncle Red: 0-65
Tiger Yellow: 66-87
Pegasus Blue: 88-100

Exactly. I will take that as you agree to that. I will post the next results then update the rubric and template.

Sounds good boss. Sorry my internet keeps going down